The family and friends cannot think of any reason she would like to leave voluntarily. Cynthia had been having many dreams of some man coming and abducting her, which might have been some sort of premonition. However, her father noticed changes in her eating habits and the way she presented herself. One lead said that she was trapped in some basement, but the police never found the house that she briefly described. A convicted drug dealer, Jose Rodriguez Jr., is a suspect, but the confession to killing Anderson was ruled out. It was believed that Cynthia Anderson overheard some conversation and knew too much. Also, during the time of her disappearance, there are two men who had been convicted of 9 murders in Toledo, Ohio. Their names are Anthony and Nathaniel Cook, but they denied killing her. The case is still open and none of the suspects have been ruled out.